• RSS Feed
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Instagram
  • You Tube
  • Search the site
Montana Environmental Information Center – MEIC
  • Montana Legislature
    • 2025 Bill Tracker
    • Legislators
    • Meeting Recordings
    • Voting Records
    • Capitol Monitor Bulletin
  • Get Informed
    • Fossil Fuels & Clean Energy
    • Hardrock Mining & Air Pollution
    • Government Accountability
    • Down to Earth: Magazine & AudioMag
    • Resources & Fact Sheets
    • About MEIC
      • MEIC Articles
      • Shop MEIC merch
  • Take Action
    • Things You Can Do This Week
    • Action Center
    • Sign up for Action Alerts
    • Events
      • MEIC Events
      • MEIC Meeting Videos
      • Conservation Calendar
  • Donate

Press Release: Montana Supreme Court Again Rebukes NorthWestern Energy on Clean Energy Projects

MEIC| March 20, 2024| Blog, News

Victory — Court requires utility to pay fine for failing to invest in community renewable projects

 

CONTACTS

Perry Wheeler, Earthjustice, 202-792-6211, pwheeler@earthjustice.org

Anne Hedges, Montana Environmental Information Center, 406-461-9546, ahedges@meic.org

 

HELENA, MT — Once again, the Montana Supreme Court has ruled NorthWestern Energy’s hostile approach to clean energy was a violation of the law. The Montana Public Service Commission (PSC) followed NorthWestern’s lead and allowed the company to ignore a requirement for the utility to invest in Montana communities by purchasing renewable energy from small community-based projects. The penalty for this violation will provide much-needed revenue to Low-Income and Tribal Energy Assistance programs. These funds are more crucial than ever after residential and business customers started suffering from NorthWestern’s steep 28% electricity rate increase approved by the PSC in the fall.

The case involved a state law that was designed to spur renewable energy development while boosting local economies. The law required public utilities to purchase a specified amount of electricity output from small, locally owned renewable energy resources. Since the law took effect in 2012, NorthWestern Energy never once complied with its purchase obligation. Instead, NorthWestern advanced a series of excuses for excluding such small renewable resources from its portfolio. And in each of those years, the PSC accepted those excuses to waive the company’s obligation to pay a penalty for its noncompliance.

In 2018, Montana Environmental Information Center, represented by Earthjustice, sued to overturn the commission’s grant of compliance waivers for two years — 2015 and 2016. In 2022, a state district court in Montana agreed and directed NorthWestern to pay a $2.5 million penalty into Montana’s Low-Income Energy Assistance fund. While the Montana legislature repealed the CREP-purchase requirements in 2021, the Montana Supreme Court ruled yesterday that NorthWestern was still obligated to pay penalties for failing to comply in 2015.

The Montana Supreme Court’s decision largely affirmed the district court’s ruling. With regard to the 2015 waiver, the court found that the PSC’s “factual findings are sparse, at best,” and “the record evidence demonstrates that NorthWestern was not prevented from compliance by ‘legitimate reasons’ beyond its control” but instead NorthWestern’s actions did not “amount to even the most marginal due diligence.” Instead, NorthWestern created unreasonable barriers for projects to be selected. The court found the PSC needed to make a more detailed determination “regarding NorthWestern’s compliance or non-compliance with its [legal] obligations in 2016.”

“It’s beyond time for NorthWestern to embrace the opportunity of renewable energy. It’s clean, affordable, and as the Supreme Court has affirmed, the law required it,” said Earthjustice attorney Emily Qiu, who represented MEIC in the case.

“NorthWestern Energy has done everything it can, including breaking the law, to avoid providing its customers with clean, affordable electricity,” said Anne Hedges, co-director of MEIC. “It’s time for the PSC to stop enabling NorthWestern’s outdated behavior. The PSC should insist NorthWestern save its customers money, reduce risks, and diversify its portfolios by investing in clean electricity instead of NorthWestern’s approach of looking in the rearview mirror. The PSC has an opportunity to help NorthWestern move forward and protect customers by adopting a rule that requires consideration of risks and costs posed to our energy system and customers’ pocketbooks by a changing climate.”

NorthWestern cannot charge its customers for the penalty it will pay for non-compliance.  The penalty must be deposited in an assistance fund, which finances low-income bill assistance and weatherization programs in Montana.

 

 

Download the legal document here.

northwestern energy

Last modified: October 15, 2024

Previous Story:
Sustainable Communities Advocate or Director
Next Story:
Court says PSC, NorthWestern Energy, violated renewable energy law
  • You might also like

  • Is NorthWestern Hoodwinking Customers as it Lures Data Centers into the State?
  • Why are NorthWestern Energy’s rates so high?
  • NorthWestern Asks to Raise Electricity Rates AGAIN — by 26% more
  • NorthWestern Tries to Shut the Public Out of Public Processes

Comments are closed.

Latest from MEIC

  • Now hiring: MEIC Administrative and Development Assistant
  • MEIC Statement on Signing of MEPA Bills
  • Webinar Recording: MEIC Weekly Legislative Update, April 10, 2025
  • Press Release: President Grants Pollution Exemption to Coal Plant that Emits Most Air Toxins in the Nation
  • Webinar Recording: Ask the Experts: NorthWestern Rate Case

Recent News

  • Anne Hedges: Legislature guts public review process despite history of protecting neighbors
  • In Montana, Republican State Legislators Fight Back After Successful Youth Climate Lawsuit
  • Don’t fix what isn’t broken; Governor should veto HB 664 | Opinion
  • Press Release: President Grants Pollution Exemption to Coal Plant that Emits Most Air Toxins in the Nation
  • Legislature advances bills loosening water quality standards

Events

MEIC Weekly Legislative Update Series
15 May 25
Montana Environmental Information Center – MEIC

Montana Environmental
Information Center

Clean and healthful.
It's your right, our mission.

Stay Connected

P: (406) 443-2520
E: meic@meic.org
324 Fuller Ave, #C-8
Helena, MT 59601

Mailing addresses:
P.O. Box 1184, Helena, MT, 59624
225 W. Front, Missoula, MT, 59802

Join MEIC’s Action Alert Network →

About MEIC

About Us
Accomplishments
Our People
Jobs and Internships
MEIC in the News
Contact Us

Get the Newsletter

* indicates required
  • RSS Feed
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Instagram
  • You Tube
  • Search the site
↑